Business discipline for agricultural development

Published by rudy Date posted on October 29, 2010

CAN BUSINESS discipline truly help agricultural development? Definitely. First of all, agriculture cannot be sustainable unless it is profitable. Secondly, the business discipline necessary to sustain profits is required for optimal agricultural development.

The table below on government interventions suggests priorities for Department of Agriculture budget use.

Background

During these critical times of global food insecurity brought by climate change, it is imperative we maximize scarce resources. This would be good not only for increasing food production, but also for improving small farmer incomes.

At the Philippine Agriculture Economics and Development Association (Paeda), we reached a consensus that the business discipline of using Return on Investment (ROI) should be a key factor in determining agricultural budget priorities.

In June 2005, I wrote an Inquirer article on “Less Politics, More Economics”. This showed very clearly that restoring and repairing irrigation facilities yielded higher returns than building new ones. However, many speculated that the latter was often preferred because of larger kickbacks.

The DA immediately took action on this. Today, we see the reversal of priority spending from new irrigation systems to restoration and repair.

Using ROI

However, using ROI should not be limited to irrigation. The table above shows preliminary ROI for other government interventions based on our recent research. However, the ROI varies depending on the specific area of the country. It is therefore important that the Local Government Units (LGUs), the Department of Agriculture (DA), and the provincial and municipal Agriculture and Fishery Councils (AFCs) conduct their own ROI estimates in their unique areas. Agriculture spending priorities can then be determined with “less politics, more economics.”

The ROI should be supplemented with other considerations. For example, if hybrid seeds appear to have a higher ROI than certified seeds in a certain area, it still should be determined if hybrid seeds should be subsidized. In areas where the land has lost much of its fertility due to too much chemical use, the ROIs may be actually negative for hybrid seeds. Even where hybrid rice is successful, there is no need for subsidies for those hybrid rice farmers who are already successful.

Shallow tube wells is another example. Though some may have a high ROI, these may be disastrous in areas where the water table is already low. In those areas, the water needed for future planting season may be used up.

Conclusion

Today, politics and other considerations often determine how the DA budget will be spent. It is recommended that the business discipline of ROI determination be used as a major factor in the final Congress DA budget item prioritization in the coming weeks.

The same ROI guideline should also be used to determine DA budget allocations at the local level. The LGUs, DA, and the AFCs can then determine which item should be funded first. They can also choose the most effective combination of government interventions in their specific areas. By using business discipline, agricultural development can optimally be achieved to attain our much needed food security and increase farmer incomes. –Ernesto Ordoñez, Philippine Daily Inquirer

(The author is chair of Agriwatch, former secretary for presidential flagship programs and projects, and former undersecretary for Agriculture, and Trade and Industry. For inquiries and suggestions, e-mail agriwatch_phil@yahoo.com or telefax 8522112)

July 2025

Nutrition Month
“Give us much more than P50 increase
for proper nutrition!”

Invoke Article 33 of the ILO Constitution
against the military junta in Myanmar
to carry out the 2021 ILO Commission of Inquiry recommendations
against serious violations of
Forced Labour and Freedom of Association protocols.

Accept National Unity Government (NUG)
of Myanmar.  Reject Military!

#WearMask #WashHands #Distancing #TakePicturesVideosturesVideos

Time to support & empower survivors. Time to spark a global conversation. Time for #GenerationEquality to #orangetheworld!

July


3 July – International Day of Cooperatives
3 Ju
ly – International Plastic Bag Free Day
 
5 July –
World Youth Skills Day 
7 July – Global Forgiveness Day
11 July – World Population Day 
17 July – World Day for
International Justice
28 July – World Nature Conservation Day
30 July – World Day against Trafficking in Persons 


Monthly Observances:

Schools Safety Month

Nutrition Month
National Disaster Consciousness Month

Weekly Observances:

Week 2: Cultural Communities Week
Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprise
Development Week
Week 3: National Science and
Technology Week
National Disability Prevention and
Rehabilitation Week
July 1-7:
National Culture Consciousness Week
July 13-19:
Philippines Business Week
Week ending last Saturday of July:
Arbor Week

 

Daily Observances:

First Saturday of July:
International Cooperative Day
in the Philippines

Categories

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.