Problem with ‘activist,’ ‘militant,’ ‘terrorist’ tags

Published by rudy Date posted on December 23, 2010

THIS REFERS to Mark Dia’s letter. (“On Ferraris and use of ‘militant’,” (Inquirer, 11/22/10) The letter raises the potentially problematic appreciation by the international arena of the term “militant” when applied to various groups in the Philippines where it has quite different senses. This is pointed out in the 2010 book “Primed and Purposeful: Armed Groups and Human Security Efforts in the Philippines” that I co-authored.

In that book, I noted Australian academic David Wright-Neville’s tentative typology of Islamist groups in Southeast Asia as a useful starting point in understanding the forces that drive the movement from unarmed struggle to armed struggle and ultimately to terrorism. Based on an increasing degree of political alienation, he has three classifications:

1. Activists—usually contain their action safely within the parameters of existing laws.

2. Militants—more inclined to push past the boundaries of existing laws, but with a self-limiting nature which reflects moral and ethical boundaries.

3. Terrorists—with no such self-limiting nature, they are led to a moral disengagement that makes it easier for them to ignore the conventional distinction between combatant and noncombatant, and to justify committing violence against a wider audience.

Using this typology, the Moro National Liberation Front (MNLF) and Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF) are militant, while the Abu Sayyaf Group (ASG), Rajah Solaiman Movement (RSM) and Jemaah Islamiyah (JI) are terrorist.

In other contexts such as Kashmir or Gaza, “militant” is almost synonymous with “terrorist,” or at the very least an armed rebel or insurgent. Malaysian academic Kamarulnizam Abdullah, writing on militant Islam in Malaysia, uses “militant” to describe the use of unlawful force and violent acts to achieve one’s political objectives, creating either public fear or hatred against the perceived enemy of the perpetrating group or would result in public disorder, with possible detrimental effects on societal cohesion. There is in fact in Malaysia a jihadi group by the name(s) Kumpulan Militan [alternatively Mujahidin] Malaysia (KMM).

In the Philippines, “militant” had a very different connotation, associated with the “peaceful but militant, vigorous but non-violent” struggle of open and legal cause-oriented groups against the Marcos dictatorship. Today, it refers mainly to open and legal national-democratic (nat-dem) organizations, and to activism associated with the leftist political coalition Bagong Alyansang Makabayan (Bayan). In fact, Bayan’s activism is often referred to as “militant activism” to distinguish it from the moderate activism of the “social-democrats” or “soc-dems.” Interestingly, the term “militant” has had almost no local application to the Moro struggles, whether to pre-martial law Moro student activism or to the MNLF and MILF.

Potentially more dangerous are the associations—and listings, proscriptions and sanctions—that come with the word “terrorist” or “terrorism” if not properly defined, especially in law; but that is another matter requiring much longer discussion. –Philippine Daily Inquirer

—SOLIMAN M. SANTOS JR.,
judge, 9th MCTC of Nabua-Bato,
Camarines Sur

September 18 –
International Equal Pay Day

“Increase wages now,
more than other cost items.
For widespread, practical equality!”

Invoke Article 33 of the ILO Constitution
against the military junta in Myanmar
to carry out the recommendations of the 2021 ILO Commission of Inquiry
against serious violations of protocols of
Forced Labour and Freedom of Association.

Accept the National Unity Government (NUG) 
of Myanmar.  Reject Military!

#WearMask #WashHands
#Report Corruption #SearchPosts #TakePicturesVideos

Time to support & empower survivors. Time to spark a global conversation. Time for #GenerationEquality to #orangetheworld!

October –

   

Monthly Observances:

Industry and Commerce Safety Month 

National Statistics Month 

Local Government Month 

Consumer Welfare Month 

Cooperative Month

National Quality and Productivity Improvement Month 

National Health and Wellness Tourism Month
National Indigenous Peoples Month

 

Weekly Observances:

Week 1: Elderly Filipino Week 

Week 2: National Health Education Week 

Local Government Week 

National Mental Health Week 

October 17-23:

National Week for Overcoming Extreme Poverty 

October 18 – 24:

United Nations Week 

Last Week:

Nurses’ Week 

Consumers’ Protection Week 

Week of the 4th Sunday:

Barrio Farmers’ Week

 

Daily Observances:

First Monday (Oct 4): Universal Children’s Day i
n the Philippines 

Oct 5: National Teachers’ Day 

Oct 10: Local Government Day 

Third Thursday (Oct 14): Conflict Resolution Day 

Oct 21: Tenants’ Emancipation day 

Oct 24: United Nations Day 

Oct 29: National Indigenous People’s Thanksgiving Day

Categories

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.