SC has last say on meaning of the law—Bernas

Published by rudy Date posted on February 11, 2012

THE Supreme Court may step in to stop any abuse of discretion during the impeachment trial of Chief Justice Renato Corona, noted constitutional expert Joaquin Bernas said Thursday.

Speaking before the Philippine Constitutional Association meeting at the Manila Hotel, Bernas, dean emeritus of the Ateneo Law School and a member of the constitutional commission that drafted the 1987 Constitution, said the Charter gave the high court the power to determine with finality the meaning of the law.

While the House of Representatives had the sole power to initiate impeachment complaints and the Senate was tasked to be the sole judge of such cases, the Supreme Court had intervened in the past to stop grave abuses of discretion, Bernas said.

He said the Court stopped the House from filing a new impeachment complaint against former Chief Justice Hilario Davide Jr. in 2003 because the law prohibited the filing of two such complaints within the same year.

The Court also stopped the House from hearing the impeachment complaint against former Ombudsman Merceditas Gutierrez in 2010, but eventually allowed it to proceed, Bernas said.

He said that even in the cases being handled by election tribunals, the high court had also intervened.

“What all this means is that the Supreme Court can come in when needed to determine the meaning of the law,” Bernas said.

“This does not mean superiority of the [high court] over the the other departments. All it means is that the Constitution has placed in the [Supreme Court] the power to determine with finality the meaning of the law. It means the superiority of the Constitution, and it just so happens that in the constitutional structure of our government, there is separation of responsibilities.

“There is no superiority of one over the others; there is only superiority of the Constitution over all.”

In an open forum afterward, Bernas said failure to disclose to the public a statement of assets, liabilities and net worth—Article 2 in Corona’s ongoing trial—was not an impeachable offense under the law.

“It seems that the law itself does not consider it grave because it allows the declarant to correct mistakes,” Bernas said in response to a question from Camarines Sur Rep. Luis Villafuerte.

He said the non-disclosure of assets in a statement was not among the high crimes included in the Constitution when it came to treason, bribery and other high crimes that would constitute betrayal of public trust.

“It’s not in the same class as treason and bribery covered by culpable violation of the Constitution and betrayal of public trust,” which implied deliberate intent, Bernas said.

He also said that if the evidence against Corona could not justify his removal or disqualification, but could only justify a lower offense, that meant Corona was not guilty in the impeachment.

The offense that must be proved was treason or other high crimes, Bernas said.

On the other hand, the Senate could still remove a person through impeachment if it believed it was for the good of the nation, Bernas said.

Commenting on the two-thirds vote needed to convict, Bernas said it was up to the Senate to decide if that applied to the 24 seats allowed by the Constitution, in which case 16 votes were needed, or to the 23 seats now filled, in which case only 15 were required.

“In my opinion, if the Senate chooses 15, that’s it. If the Senate chooses 16, so that’s it,” Bernas said. –Rey E. Requejo and Macon R. Araneta, Manila Standard Today

July 2025

Nutrition Month
“Give us much more than P50 increase
for proper nutrition!”

Invoke Article 33 of the ILO Constitution
against the military junta in Myanmar
to carry out the 2021 ILO Commission of Inquiry recommendations
against serious violations of
Forced Labour and Freedom of Association protocols.

Accept National Unity Government (NUG)
of Myanmar.  Reject Military!

#WearMask #WashHands #Distancing #TakePicturesVideosturesVideos

Time to support & empower survivors. Time to spark a global conversation. Time for #GenerationEquality to #orangetheworld!

July


3 July – International Day of Cooperatives
3 Ju
ly – International Plastic Bag Free Day
 
5 July –
World Youth Skills Day 
7 July – Global Forgiveness Day
11 July – World Population Day 
17 July – World Day for
International Justice
28 July – World Nature Conservation Day
30 July – World Day against Trafficking in Persons 


Monthly Observances:

Schools Safety Month

Nutrition Month
National Disaster Consciousness Month

Weekly Observances:

Week 2: Cultural Communities Week
Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprise
Development Week
Week 3: National Science and
Technology Week
National Disability Prevention and
Rehabilitation Week
July 1-7:
National Culture Consciousness Week
July 13-19:
Philippines Business Week
Week ending last Saturday of July:
Arbor Week

 

Daily Observances:

First Saturday of July:
International Cooperative Day
in the Philippines

Categories

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.