Supreme Court draws flak over ‘judicial legislation’

Published by rudy Date posted on April 28, 2009

SENATORS said yesterday the Supreme Court went beyond its constitutional bounds and engaged in “judicial legislation” when it upheld the validity of the election of 32 more party-list representatives.

Senator Joker Arroyo said the justices erred when they ruled, in last week’s Banat v. Comelec decision, that there should be 55 seats for party-list representatives and then provided the formula for filling up the entire 55 seats.

“The high court has invaded the legislative domain of Congress. It substituted its formula instead of waiting for Congress to correct it,” Arroyo said in a privilege speech.

He cited a constitutional provision that the House of Representatives “shall be composed of not more than 250 members, unless otherwise provided by law” and out of the membership “the party-list representatives shall constitute 20 percent.” He said that means 200 district representatives and 50 party-list representatives or an 80-20 ratio.

Senator Miriam Defensor Santiago said the court’s ruling would create a big headache for the bureaucracy and questioned why it had to take effect immediately instead of waiting for the 2010 elections.

“Where is the urgent necessity of having this new system or formula implemented immediately? Is there something that is extremely dangerous to our government, is there something that is not beneficial if we do not have these people right now?” Santiago said. “The Supreme Court solved one question but opened an entire Pandora’s box.”

The government, she said, is completely unprepared for the influx of a large number of party-list representatives.

She said the House does not have the physical facilities, much less the appropriations, to accommodate the new members, and their staff.

Senator Richard Gordon argued the justices should have dismissed the Banat petition and left it entirely to Congress to determine its membership through legislation.

Gordon, former chairman of the committee on constitutional amendments, said there is no need for party-list representation in Congress since the various sectors are already represented by senators and congressmen.

“The idea of having party-list representatives is superfluity because it made the law-making process more complicated. The more members Congress has, the longer are the debates,” he said.

He added that party-list representation is suited to a parliamentary system, not a presidential system of government.

Arroyo said that over the years, the House has been creating additional legislative districts so that it now has 220 district representatives and 22 party-list representatives or a total of 242 members.

Although the House has not exceeded the 250-member limit, the creation of additional congressional districts has encroached on the 20-percent membership allotted for party-list representatives, he said.

Arroyo said the latest ruling contradicts the court’s July l6, 2008 decision, in the Sema v. Comelec case, “that there is a need now for Congress to increase by law the allowable membership of the House, even before Congress can create new provinces.” –Fel V. Maragay, Manila Standard Today

September 18 –
International Equal Pay Day

“Increase wages now,
more than other cost items.
For widespread, practical equality!”

Invoke Article 33 of the ILO Constitution
against the military junta in Myanmar
to carry out the recommendations of the 2021 ILO Commission of Inquiry
against serious violations of protocols of
Forced Labour and Freedom of Association.

Accept the National Unity Government (NUG) 
of Myanmar.  Reject Military!

#WearMask #WashHands
#Report Corruption #SearchPosts #TakePicturesVideos

Time to support & empower survivors. Time to spark a global conversation. Time for #GenerationEquality to #orangetheworld!

October –

   

Monthly Observances:

Industry and Commerce Safety Month 

National Statistics Month 

Local Government Month 

Consumer Welfare Month 

Cooperative Month

National Quality and Productivity Improvement Month 

National Health and Wellness Tourism Month
National Indigenous Peoples Month

 

Weekly Observances:

Week 1: Elderly Filipino Week 

Week 2: National Health Education Week 

Local Government Week 

National Mental Health Week 

October 17-23:

National Week for Overcoming Extreme Poverty 

October 18 – 24:

United Nations Week 

Last Week:

Nurses’ Week 

Consumers’ Protection Week 

Week of the 4th Sunday:

Barrio Farmers’ Week

 

Daily Observances:

First Monday (Oct 4): Universal Children’s Day i
n the Philippines 

Oct 5: National Teachers’ Day 

Oct 10: Local Government Day 

Third Thursday (Oct 14): Conflict Resolution Day 

Oct 21: Tenants’ Emancipation day 

Oct 24: United Nations Day 

Oct 29: National Indigenous People’s Thanksgiving Day

Categories

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.