CARP did more harm than good to farm sector, says economist

Published by rudy Date posted on August 21, 2020

By: Karl R. Ocampo – Reporter, Philippine Daily Inquirer, 21 Aug 2020

The government’s Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Program (CARP) has triggered severe fragmentation of agricultural lands, ultimately disempowering farmers who do not have the capital to sustain production on their own while struggling to pay their obligations so they can get their land titles.

According to economist and national scientist Raul Fabella, the government lost as much as P340 billion in forgone farm production in 2019 due to CARP. He warned that the same amount of losses might be seen in the coming years.

The figure was computed by factoring in the sector’s contribution to the economy and the estimated potential losses brought about by the land reform law.

Based on a study, the program reduced the country’s average farm size by 37 percent and the average output per hectare by 17 percent, resulting in losses amounting to P340 billion.The land reform program was meant to empower farmers by giving them their own lands, but 22 years since it was enacted into law, the opposite has happened.

Without consistent distribution of support services to the beneficiaries, some of the landholdings that were given to ARBs (agrarian reform beneficiaries) were now being illegally leased out, while some became idle lands as farmers do not have enough capital to sustain production.

Under the law, land beneficiaries may sell their landholdings only after 10 years.

“The effect of fragmentation is really serious,” Roehlano Briones, senior researcher of the Philippine Institute for Development Studies, said. “A lot of the beneficiaries [of CARP] are delinquent payers and are held back by their debts to lease or sell their lands. If they want to use their lands for any transaction, they need to have clean titles.”

The enormous losses have prompted lawmakers to consider extending partial debt condonation to ARBs, which would enable them to have clean titles and allow them to either lease or sell their lands. This, in turn, presents opportunities for both the government and the private sector to venture into commercial crop production.

Fabella said the proposed measure would result in losses to the government amounting to only P58 billion, versus the potential gain from freeing up landholdings from CARP.

Currently, the ARBs’ obligations for the land transferred to them under the land reform law are slapped with an annual interest of 6 percent and should be paid in 30 years. However, only 17 percent of ARBs are paying their amortization, resulting in massive loan defaults.

Agriculture Secretary William Dar, who was the first secretary to institutionalize farm consolidation, was also receptive to the debt condonation proposal.

He stressed that debt condonation would allow land markets to operate with much ease, including the buying and selling of lands for agricultural purposes. However, the secretary also aired his reservations.

“[The proposal] should be accompanied by accelerated individual titling of lands still under Cloas (certificates of land ownership award), and there has to be an increase in land ownership retention ceiling to around 25 ha for economies of scale to be achieved by agricultural investors,” he said.

He added that the retention ceiling would “not result in monopoly ownership of land or landlordism, as certain quarters feared.

Federation of Free Farmers national chair Raul Montemayor said debt condonation would finally give land reform beneficiaries the freedom to decide on what to do with their lands.

“Some may sell their lands and distribute the money to their children. Others may just enjoy the money. Our farmers are already old. This could give them relief,” he said.

September 18 –
International Equal Pay Day

“Increase wages now,
more than other cost items.
For widespread, practical equality!”

Invoke Article 33 of the ILO Constitution
against the military junta in Myanmar
to carry out the recommendations of the 2021 ILO Commission of Inquiry
against serious violations of protocols of
Forced Labour and Freedom of Association.

Accept the National Unity Government (NUG) 
of Myanmar.  Reject Military!

#WearMask #WashHands
#Report Corruption #SearchPosts #TakePicturesVideos

Time to support & empower survivors. Time to spark a global conversation. Time for #GenerationEquality to #orangetheworld!

October –

   

Monthly Observances:

Industry and Commerce Safety Month 

National Statistics Month 

Local Government Month 

Consumer Welfare Month 

Cooperative Month

National Quality and Productivity Improvement Month 

National Health and Wellness Tourism Month
National Indigenous Peoples Month

 

Weekly Observances:

Week 1: Elderly Filipino Week 

Week 2: National Health Education Week 

Local Government Week 

National Mental Health Week 

October 17-23:

National Week for Overcoming Extreme Poverty 

October 18 – 24:

United Nations Week 

Last Week:

Nurses’ Week 

Consumers’ Protection Week 

Week of the 4th Sunday:

Barrio Farmers’ Week

 

Daily Observances:

First Monday (Oct 4): Universal Children’s Day i
n the Philippines 

Oct 5: National Teachers’ Day 

Oct 10: Local Government Day 

Third Thursday (Oct 14): Conflict Resolution Day 

Oct 21: Tenants’ Emancipation day 

Oct 24: United Nations Day 

Oct 29: National Indigenous People’s Thanksgiving Day

Categories

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit. Ut elit tellus, luctus nec ullamcorper mattis, pulvinar dapibus leo.